Row houses in Denver
Row houses in Denver. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress (public domain).

Equal Parenting Time in Colorado: When 50/50 Works and When It Fails

Colorado has no presumption of equal parenting time, yet 50/50 is the most common outcome for two involved parents who live near each other. How judges evaluate it, which schedules fit which ages, when it is a poor fit, and what it does to child support.

  1. →Parental Responsibilities, the practice page
  2. →All articles

· 6 min read · Aaron Herzberg · Children

Colorado law contains no presumption that parents should share time equally. The statute never says 50/50, and the bench book Colorado judges use says flatly that no such presumption exists. Yet for two involved parents who live near each other and can speak civilly, equal time is the most common result, by agreement or after trial. The practical question in most Denver custody cases is not whether 50/50 is the default. It is whether 50/50 fits this child, these two homes, and these two schedules.

This article explains how judges evaluate an equal-time request, which schedules suit which ages, where 50/50 is a poor fit, what it does to child support now that every overnight counts, and how to respond when the other parent wants 50/50 for reasons that have nothing to do with the child.

No Presumption, but a Statute That Leans Toward Both Parents

The legislative declaration in C.R.S. § 14-10-124(1) says that in most circumstances it is in everyone's best interest to encourage "frequent and continuing contact" between each parent and the children, and it urges parents to share the rights and responsibilities of child-rearing. That is a policy, not a formula. The court must allocate parenting time according to the child's best interests, giving paramount consideration to the child's safety and physical, mental, and emotional needs, and it may not presume that either parent is better because of sex.

In re Marriage of Collins and Goldstone (Colo. App. 2023) shows the discretion at work. The trial court awarded the mother primary parenting time because she had been the full-time caregiver, the child had exceptional medical needs she was uniquely equipped to meet, and the father's work schedule had limited his time. The appellate court affirmed, noting the trial court's broad discretion over parenting time and that every presumption favors upholding its decision. Equal time is common because the evidence often supports it, not because the law starts there.

Row houses in Denver
Row houses in Denver. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress (public domain).

How Judges Evaluate a 50/50 Request

Among the best-interests factors in § 14-10-124(1.5)(a), a handful do most of the work when equal time is contested:

  • Physical proximity of the parents "as this relates to the practical considerations of parenting time." A child has to get to the same school from both homes on a Tuesday morning.
  • The child's adjustment to home, school, and community, and the child's own wishes if the child is mature enough to express reasoned and independent preferences.
  • Whether each parent's past pattern of involvement reflects a system of values, time commitment, and mutual support. Judges want to know who took the child to the pediatrician, who knew the teacher's name, and who handled the 2:00 a.m. fever before anyone filed.
  • The mental and physical health of everyone involved, and any finding of domestic violence or child abuse, which the court must address before it reaches the other factors.
  • Each parent's ability to encourage the child's relationship with the other, and to put the child's needs first. For decision-making, credible evidence of the ability to cooperate.

The bench book adds the practical questions judges ask: the children's ages, maturity, and temperaments; whether both parents have actually parented; special needs; distance between homes; whether the parents can communicate; and how child care and activities will work. Two homes in the same school attendance area, two parents with school-hour jobs, and a shared calendar make equal time an easy call. One parent in Castle Rock and a school in Denver do not.

The Common Equal Schedules and the Ages They Suit

Equal time can be arranged many ways, and the choice matters more than the label.

  • Week-on, week-off. One exchange a week, usually at school on Friday or Monday. Simple and stable for tweens and teenagers. For younger children a full week apart is long; add a midweek dinner or overnight.
  • 2-2-5-5. Monday and Tuesday always with one parent, Wednesday and Thursday always with the other, and alternating three-day weekends. Every weekday is predictable, no stretch exceeds five days, and it suits elementary-age children well.
  • 3-4-4-3. Shorter blocks, more exchanges, and no stretch longer than four days. It works for preschool and early elementary children with parents who cooperate, and it wears out parents who do not.
  • 2-2-3. The most exchanges of all, on a two-week rotation. It fits toddlers who need to see both parents often, and almost nobody else.

Whatever the pattern, the holiday schedule overrides it, exchanges should happen at school or daycare where the calendar allows, and the plan should say what changes at middle school. A schedule chosen for a four-year-old should not still be running for a fourteen-year-old by inertia.

When 50/50 Is a Poor Fit

Judges decline equal time, or parents wisely stop asking for it, in recognizable situations:

  • Infants and very young children, who generally do better with frequent, shorter contact than with long blocks away from a primary caregiver. Colorado courts have upheld daytime-only schedules for a toddler where the evidence supported it.
  • Distance. When the homes are far enough apart that one parent's weekday time means a long commute to school, equal time is purchased at the child's expense.
  • High conflict. A 2-2-3 schedule means six exchanges every two weeks, and each one is a flashpoint. Equal time in a high-conflict family requires either genuine cooperation or a plan engineered so the parents never meet.
  • A parent who travels. Equal time on paper becomes 30/70 in practice, with the child spending the difference with a sitter, and every trip becomes a right-of-first-refusal argument.
  • Safety. Where domestic violence or child abuse is claimed, C.R.S. § 14-10-124(4) requires the court to address it before the other factors, and the resulting plan may involve supervised time, restricted overnights, or conditions on alcohol and substance use. Substance misuse without abuse goes to the health factor and produces similar conditions.
  • The child's own needs. Special medical or educational needs, a therapy schedule, or a temperament that struggles with transitions can all outweigh the appeal of symmetry.

Equal Time and Child Support Now That Every Overnight Counts

For years the support fight in an equal-time case was really a fight about crossing the old shared-care threshold. For orders entered or modified on or after March 1, 2026, that cliff is gone. The amended C.R.S. § 14-10-115(8) uses a parenting-time table that credits every overnight, reaching a 50 percent credit at 182.5 overnights, and it caps the result so no parent pays more than he or she would with no overnights at all. Equal time does not mean zero support; the higher earner still typically pays, because the credit is applied to each parent's share of a combined obligation. What changed is that the difference between 170 and 182 overnights is now a modest amount of money rather than an all-or-nothing outcome. This blog's post on the parenting-time table walks through the arithmetic.

When One Parent Wants 50/50 for the Wrong Reasons

Every custody lawyer has seen the equal-time request that is really about something else: lowering child support, keeping the house, punishing the other parent, or a new partner's idea of fairness. Two responses fail. Disparaging the other parent turns the encourage-contact factor against you. Refusing to negotiate any expansion of time signals rigidity.

What works is evidence and a counterproposal. Assemble the past-pattern record: school and medical contacts, the activity calendar, who the emergency contact was. Test the proposed schedule against the practical factors and ask the other side to explain the Tuesday. Then offer something the court can adopt, such as a phased schedule that expands toward equal time as the child ages or as the other parent's involvement proves out, with review points written into the plan. A parent who secures equal time to cut support and then does not exercise it faces the enforcement statute, which treats failing to exercise parenting time as a violation, and a motion to modify built on what actually happened.

Talk to a Denver Divorce Attorney About Equal Parenting Time

Aaron Herzberg is a divorce attorney in Greenwood Village, Colorado, serving Denver and the Front Range, with more than 30 years of trial experience and a practice focused on divorce, custody, and financially complex family law. Whether you are seeking equal time or resisting it, the case is won on the record of who did the parenting before anyone filed, and that record should be assembled early. A first meeting is a paid consultation, not a free call and not a sales pitch.

Read the full guides on DenverDivorce.com: Parenting Time in Colorado and Colorado Parenting-Time Schedules.

Educational information only, not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Contact me now.
Three fields, or call or text. My office calls back the same business day.
Keep reading

Where to go next.

The next article, the ones that belong with it, and the practice page on this topic.

If this sounds like your situation, start with a confidential conversation.

A consultation is a working session, in person in Greenwood Village or by video: we go through your situation and I tell you what I would do. One fixed fee, quoted when we schedule. Your note reaches me directly; my assistant runs the conflicts check and books the meeting.